Thursday, June 21, 2007



June isn't exactly the typical season for stews but a week ago the weather was a bit chilly, chilly for June that is, (like my graduation) and I had been eyeing this carbonnade recipe for quite some time. Carbonnade is a hearty Belgian stew that centers around three main ingredients: beef, beer, and onions. The original Cook's Illustrated recipe recommends using a traditional Belgian ale or another dark ale or beer like Chimay, Newcastle Brown Ale, Anchor Steam, and Samuel Smith Taddy Porter. I only had Guiness at home, which the folks at CI said could make for a slightly bitter stew. So to balance this bitterness, I opted to use some sweet Vidalia onions rather than yellow onions. The stew was simple to make but really delicious and rich. We ate it over rice but you can also serve it over egg noodles or potatoes. Mmm... meat and rice, my type of meal.

- If you can't get top blade steaks you can substitute a chuck roast.
- Recommended ales: Chimay, Newcastle Brown Ale, Anchor Steam, and Samuel Smith Taddy Porter
- If you are using one of the four recommended beers, use yellow onions, using red or white onions with those beers can make the stew a bit too sweet.
- If you only have Guiness Stout like me, use sweeter red or white onions to balance the bitterness.
- Slice half the onions into 1/4 in slices and the other half into 1/8 in slices. The thinner slices will melt into the stew but the thicker slices will stick around and melt in your mouth.

Carbonnade a la Flamande
Adapted from Cook's Illustrated

3 - 3 1/2 lb blade steak, trimmed of gristle and fat then cut into 1 inch pieces
2 lbs yellow onions, 3 medium or 2 large onions (see note about slicing)
2 cloves of garlic, minced or pressed
3 Tbsp of AP flour
1 C chicken broth
1 12 oz. bottle of one of the recommended Belgian ales
Bouquet Garni: 4 - 6 sprigs of parsley, 3 - 4 sprigs of thyme, 2 bay leaves tied together with twine
1 Tbsp red wine vinegar or cider vinegar
salt and pepper to taste
3 Tbsp vegetable oil

Dry beef with some paper towels and season with salt and pepper. Heat 2 tsp of oil over medium high heat in a Dutch oven. When the oil is barely beginning to smoke add 1/3 of the beef. Cook the beef on the first side, without moving until browned, about 2 - 3 minutes. Then use tongs and flip the beef pieces over and brown on the second side. Transfer to a bowl, add more oil and repeat with half of the remaining beef. If the browned bits on the bottom of the pan are getting too dark, add some chicken broth, scrape up the brown bits, then pour this liquid into the bowl with the beef. Add more oil, and brown the remaining beef.

Reduce the heat to medium and add another tbsp of oil into the Dutch oven. Add the onions and cook until they are lightly browned. Add the flour and garlic. Cook until the flour is lightly browned, about 2 minutes. Add the chicken broth, beer, and vinegar. Scrape up any additional browned bits, then add the beef and bouquet. I usually add salt and pepper now so the beef will pick up flavor as it cooks but I don't add too much salt since the stew will reduce a little and the flavors will concentrate. Salt to taste after cooking.

Increase the heat and bring the contents of the pot back up to a boil then lower the heat to a bare simmer. Simmer over really low heat for about 2 - 3 hours, or until the beef is tender. Discard the bouquet and salt to taste. Sprinkle with a bit of fresh parlsey and serve over rice or egg noodles or alongside potatoes.


Sig said...

OMG Amy, that is one yummy looking stew... meat, beer and onions... what more do you want :)... I would love this over rice too...

Anonymous said...

This recipe is similar to our Trinidad Stew Beef :) but we added the influences of some other cultures as well :)

Lydia (The Perfect Pantry) said...

Definitely what I'd think of as a winter recipe -- or one of those August nights in the mountains when the day has been warm but the evening gets cool. Thanks for the recipe.

Peabody said...

Well beef, beer and onions...sure to make my husband happy!

Anonymous said...

I like the combination of beef, beer and onions in a stew. For me, stew does not depends on seasons. I just eat it whenever I feel like it :D

Anonymous said...

Looks delicious and filling, and served over rice? YUM.

Ari (Baking and Books)

Amy said...

Thanks! Rice is really yummy with this stew. We have rice with pretty much everything. :D

Your trinidad beef stew looks mouthwatering! Thanks for sharing the recipe!

I agree, nothing like stew to warm you up. :)

Men just love their beef and beer, lol.

The trio definitely made a great combo for stew. I love stew all the time too, unless it's dreadfully hot, then it's a cool noodle dish.

Thanks! It was sooo filling. :D

Helene said...

That is are my cyber sister: my mom's side is from Provence and my dad is from Belgium, so you made me happy with the Pissaladiere and now the Carbonnade (from the Flemmish part of Belgium), his signature dish!
Great reendition!

Peter M said...

Great looking Carbonnade...I'm digging your blog!

Amy said...

Yay cyber sister, now if only I can pick up those awesome baking vibes from you. :D *hugs*

AW thanks! :)

Unknown said...

This looks really delicious. I would suggest adding a little mustard to the stew as it will give it a really nice flavour. If you don't like to use flour to bind the stew, you can use a slice of bread instead. You can find this method in my personal recipe for Flemish Carbonnade


Blog Widget by LinkWithin